Considering they're the most profitable film series of Hollywood's Golden Era -- and the only one to receive a special Academy Award ("for its achievement in representing the American way of life'') -- the Hardy Family films are awfully late arrivals on DVD, with six of them released recently by the Warner Archive Collection as "The Andy Hardy Collection, Vol. 1.''
The Hardy films seemed quaintly dated to me when I first encountered them in the mid-1960s on WNBC's "Movie Four'' (WCBS, which began rolling out much of the MGM library back in 1956, passed on the series, the station's head programmer explained to me years later, because of Metro's insistence that stations purchase the Hardy, Kildare/Gillespie and Maisie series as a package). My first article about movies, published for my high school newspaper in Queens, the Bryant Clipper, complained that Mickey Rooney's eponymous Andy Hardy was so totally unlike contemporary teenagers.
I hadn't watched any of the films since. "Love Laughs at Andy Hardy'' (1946) -- the unsuccessful final film that ended the series proper (there was an unfortunate, Rooney-produced attempt to revive the series, "Andy Hardy Comes Home'' that I actually saw on its original theatrical run in 1958 at Astoria's long-gone Grand Theatre) -- slipped into the public domain after MGM failed to renew its copyright in 1974. By 1980 it was among the earliest major-studio titles to turn up in bad dupes on VHS. MGM/UA Home Video didn't get around to releasing six other Hardys (which by then, along with 10 others, were owned by Turner Entertainment) on VHS until 1990.
Those six standalone releases included "Love Finds Andy Hardy,'' the series' most famous episode (featuring Judy Garland), which was released by Warner Home Video on DVD in 2004 and is currently out of print, as well as three films in the new DVD set: "Andy Hardy Meets Debutante,'' "Andy Hardy's Private Secretary'' and "Life Begins for Andy Hardy.''
The Hardy series was a spinoff of Clarence Brown's 1935 adaptation of Eugene O'Neill's family comedy "Ah Wilderness'' (1935) which featured Rooney, new to MGM, as the younger brother (he played the older brother in the flop musical remake "Summer Holiday'' in 1948, which bookends the Hardy series; both are available from the Warner Archive) in early 20th century Connecticut. O'Neill not being amenable to a sequel, the principal cast (Lionel Barrymore, Spring Byington, Rooney and Eric Linden but not Wallace Beery) were reunited for "A Family Affair'' (1937), a contemporary comedy about the family of an Idaho judge based "Skidding,'' a 1929 Broadway hit by Auriana Rouverol.

It was so successful that MGM raja Louis B. Mayer ordered up a series to be directed by "Family Affair'' helmer George B. Seitz, a veteran of the silent era ("Perils of Pauline'') who had turned out a procession of quick but stylish B thrillers for Metro's B-movie unit. The earliest film in the Warner Archive set is the beginning of the series proper, "You're Only Young Once'' (also 1937). Linden's character was given the heave-ho, as was his wife, Andy's married eldest sister.
Character actors Lewis Stone and Fay Holden replaced Barrymore (who would shortly begin enacting Dr. Gillespie from a wheelchair in the Dr. Kildare series) and Byington, who had begun playing Mrs. Jones in Fox's more downmarket, and frustratingly unavailable, Jones Family series. To explain Holden's accent, they made Mrs. Hardy and her spinster schoolteacher sister (Sara Haden, carried over from "You're Only Young Once'') Canadians.
Jed Prouty, who played Mr. Jones in the rival Fox series, turns up briefly as a newspaper editor who precipitates a financial crisis for the Hardys in "You're Only Young Once,'' which devotes roughly equal time to the romantic travails of siblings Andy and older sister Marian (Cecilia Parker) while vacationing on Catalina Island.
The non-chronological set skips forward to the Hardys' fifth adventure, "Out West With the Hardys,'' one of eight Rooney films (most notably "Boys Town'') released in 1938. By this point, the Hardys were no longer B pictures (which supported A pictures) but mid-budget programmers that could play at the top of a double bill. MGM even sent Seitz out to Arizona's Monument Valley to shoot backgrounds projected behind the Hardys -- shortly before John Ford claimed he "discovered'' the place for "Stagecoach.''
"Judge Hardy and Son'' (1939), the eighth installment, was released the year that Rooney became Hollywood's top box-office attraction (a title he held for two more years) and he received a special Oscar -- Rooney and Deann Durbin were cited for their "significant contribution in bringing to the screen the spirit and personification of youth, and as juvenile players setting a high standard of ability and achievement.'' (The following year, he received a Best Actor nomination for "Babes in Arms''). Understandably, which far outgrossed MGM's prestige pictures, focused more and more on Andy.
Reputedly the schmaltziest of the series, "Judge Hardy and Son'' centers around a medical crisis for Mrs. Hardy (and no, she isn't treated by Dr. Kildare). Carey Wilson, one of several A-list screenwriters who toiled on the series, claimed that Mayer personally wrote Andy's prayer for his mother's recovery. In the movie's other plot thread, Andy is assigned by Judge Hardy to track down the estranged daughter of an elderly couple (Maria Ouspenskaya, the same year she was Oscar-nominated for "Love Affair,'' and Egon Brecher) facing forclosure on their home. Andy's sleuthing technique includes dating three cute girls who may be the couple's granddaughter, much to the annoyance of Andy's long-suffering steady, Polly Benedict (Ann Rutherford, Scarlett's middle sister in "Gone With the Wind'').

The set skips ahead to three titles presented in chronological order. "Andy Hardy Meets Debutante'' (1940) brings back Garland's afflent "ugly duckling'' character, Betsy Booth, still mooning over Andy who thinks she's too much of a "child'' to see as a prospective romance.
Though she's a debutante, Betsy isn't the title character. That's Daphne, played by Diana Lewis, one of many MGM stars who cycled through the series and best remembered as the future Mrs. William Powell. Andy, smitten with her photographs, fibs to Polly and his best male pal Beezy (George Breakston) that he and Daphe have met.
Andy is mortified when Judge Hardy takes the family along on a business trip to New York (in an orphange subplot designed to bring back memories of "Boys Town'') because Polly and Beezy expect him to bring back a picture of him with Daphne.
Betsy tries to help Andy on his quest, because hick-town Andy is ill-equipped to handle the Big Apple, which he refers to as a "den of sin.'' But in MGM's version of the city, even the nighclub manager (Cy Kendall) that Andy stiffs for a hefty $37.50 tab turns out to be a soft touch.
Clocking in at 89 minutes, "Debutante'' and the other two films in the set feature "A" picture trimmings, including two musical numbers by Garland (including a wonderful rendition of "Alone'') in this cast. While the cast never left the MGM lot, the studio did send doubles for the busy Judy and Mickey to be photographed from the rear outside Grant's Tomb. Their horse-drawn ride through Central Park at dawn may be totally bogus but it's also quite charming.
The final two films in "The Andy Hardy Collection, Vol. 1'' run longer than 100 minutes and are indistinguishable from MGM "A'' pictures like the Thin Man series. "Andy Hardy's Private Secretary'' (1941) is Kathryn Grayson while "Life Begins for Andy Hardy'' (1941) brings Rooney back to Manhattan again for one last series entry with Garland (whose numbers were unfortunately cut this time).
They don't sing and dance together like in their musicals -- that would make Andy less relatable -- but their chemistry together is perhaps the biggest delight of the Hardy series. Which, I have to admit is also worth seeing for its unusually painstaking depiction of small-town American life before World War II, even if it probably is more reflective of L.B. Mayer's fantasies than the real thing.

Today's Warner Archieve releases are mostly westerns, most notably "The Squaw Man'' (1914) -- reputedly the first feature shot in Hollywood, for the Jesse L. Lasky Feature Play Co., soon to be absorbed into Paramount -- which is offered as a double feature with Cecil B. DeMille's 1931 MGM sound remake starring Warner Baxter and Dolores Del Rio, aka Mrs. Cedric Gibbons (DeMille shares a byline for the earlier one with Oscar Apfel).
There's also a second volume of "The Monogram Cowboy Collection'' comprised of eight features strarring Whip Wilson or Rod Cameron, as well as Richard Brooks' "The Last Hunt'' (Robert Taylor, Stewart Granger), Burt Kennedy's "Welcome to Hard Times'' (Henry Fonda, Janice Rule) and Jerry Thorpe's "Day of the Evil Gun'' (Glenn Ford, Arthur Kenedy).
Two musical composer biopics that were previously exclusive to Movie Unlimited are now available directly from WAC: "The Great Waltz'' (1938) with Ferdinand Gravet(y) as Johann Strauss the younger, with Luise Rainer; and "Rhapsody in Blue'' starring Robert Alda as George Gershwin and Oscar Levant as himself.
No comments:
Post a Comment